- "The Red Wedding, they're calling it. Walder Frey committed sacrilege that day. He shared bread and salt with the Starks. He offered them guest right. The gods will have their vengeance... Frey will burn in the seventh hell for what he did."
- ―A farmer loyal to House Tully curses Walder Frey for his blatant violation of guest right.
Guest right is an ancient and sacred tradition in Westeros. When a guest, be he common born or noble, eats the food and drinks the drink off a host's table beneath the host's roof, the guest right is invoked. Once invoked, neither the guest can harm his host nor the host harm his guest for the length of the guest's stay.
Guest right is considered one of the most basic social rules of all civilized men. Every major religion in Westeros - the Old Gods of the Forest, the Faith of the Seven, even the Drowned God of the Iron Islands - holds guest right to be one of the most sacred and inviolable social rules. Every lordship or kingdom since the dawn of civilization has had secular laws protecting guest right.
Guest right, or at least the safe conduct of ambassadors, is also present in Essos. When Grey Worm, the leader of Daenerys Targaryen's Unsullied army, offered to slice out the tongue of Mero after he made one too many uncivil remarks towards her, she politely declined since the man was their guest (though this did not stop her from ordering him to be killed first if it came to battle). Razdal mo Eraz, when meeting with Daenerys, was snarled at aggressively by her dragons, and complained that she had promised him safe passage; while Daenerys acknowledged this, she also acknowledged that the dragons themselves had made no such promises and were reacting to his threatening dialogue towards their mother.
- "It wasn't for murder the gods cursed the Rat Cook, or for serving the King's son in a pie... he killed a guest beneath his roof... that's something the gods can't forgive."
- ―Bran Stark
Several infamous examples of violation of guest right include:
- The Rat Cook, a legendary figure who allegedly lived centuries ago, who killed the son of a King while they were guests at the Nightfort. He then baked the flesh of the King's son into a meat pie, and served it back to his own father, who unwittingly enjoyed it so much that he asked for a second piece. The gods were not offended by the murder (as a man has a right to vengeance), nor even by the cooking of the son into a pie, but for violating the protection of guest right, as the laws of hospitality are sacred above all others.
- Although few are aware of what really happened, Jaime Lannister violated guest right when he attempted to kill Bran Stark while he was a guest of Bran's father, Eddard Stark, at Winterfell. Jaime attempted to kill a member of his host's family, however, not the host himself. Jaime was never formally punished for this, though the loss of his hand and subsequent ordeal could be considered as such.
- The Mutiny at Craster's Keep. Craster grudgingly accepts the remaining members of Jeor Mormont's ranging party into his home and gave them shelter, but abuses and mocks them as well as their fallen comrades, as well as this, Craster gave them as little food as possible and fed them "bread cuts with sawdust". One of the brothers even dies from starvation. This leads to a verbal confrontation that culminated with ranger Karl Tanner calling his host "a daughter-fucking, wildling bastard." Despite his assertion that he was "a godly man" just a moment earlier, an enraged Craster attempts to kill his guest. Karl kills Craster first by stabbing him in the throat. Even though this was an act of self-defense, Jeor Mormont makes it clear that he considers this a violation of guest right, warning that "The gods will curse us for this. By all the laws—" before he too is mortally wounded by Rast. Karl, Rast and all the other mutineers are subsequently killed by their former brothers, Karl himself ironically with Mormont's former blade.
- The Red Wedding. Robb Stark, Talisa Stark, Catelyn Stark, and their bannermen are murdered by their host, Walder Frey, after he had formally extended guest right by ceremonially sharing bread and salt with them, and following the wedding feast of Robb's uncle Lord Edmure Tully and Roslin Frey. By a twist of fate, Arya Stark, who saw how the Freys desecrated her brother's corpse by sewing Grey Wind's head onto his body, avenges her family. First, she kills Lothar Frey and Black Walder for killing Talisa and Catelyn respectively and cooks their flesh into pies that she serves to their father (just as the Rat Cook did to the king's son) before killing him too. Arya then poisons all the Frey men who participated, bringing House Frey to ruin. Tywin Lannister and Roose Bolton, who planned the betrayal and took part in it respectively, also die in ironic fashion. Tywin is ultimately shot with a crossbow (same as Robb, Catelyn, and their bannermen were) by his son Tyrion and Roose is fatally stabbed in a manner similar to when he killed Robb by his bastard son Ramsay Bolton and their houses are eventually brought to ruin by their children.
- Lady Olenna Tyrell, violated guest rights by conspiring with Petyr Baelish to assassinate King Joffrey at his own wedding, in which she was a guest of the crown.
- The Hound beats up the farmer who let him and Arya Stark stay in his house, and takes his money. The Hound had earlier remarked that "guest right don't mean much any more". The Hound is nearly killed after this, but survives and eventually regrets doing the deed, since the farmer killed himself and his daughter rather than starve. He even goes so far as to bury them and tries to give them faith of the seven funeral rites; he cannot, however, remember the rites and instead just declares that they both "deserved better" than what they received.
- Ludd Whitehill breaks guest right when, after inviting Lord Rodrik Forrester, Lady Elissa Forrester and either Duncan Tuttle or Ser Royland Degore to Highpoint to discuss the release of Ryon Forrester and offering them bread and salt, Ludd wounds Ryon and threatens to have Rodrik and his guests killed with his soldiers ready to kill them with crossbows at any second.
- In the Telltale game series, if Asher Forrester is Lord of Ironrath during the Battle of Ironrath then Asher plans to ambush or poison Lord Ludd Whitehill when they dine together in Ironrath to discuss the terms of House Forrester's surrender. Asher does have the option to go through with the plan or to change his mind and call it off, however if he calls it off then Elissa Forrester violates it instead by attacking Ludd, regardless of Asher's choice a fight breaks out leading to the death of Ludd or his son Gryff Whitehill.
- When Jon Snow comes to treat with King-Beyond-the-Wall Mance Rayder during the Battle of Castle Black, Mance shares food and drink with him, and they even toast those on both sides who fell in the heavy fighting the night before. Mance then sees Jon eyeing a cooking knife, and quickly deduces that Jon's real reason for coming was to assassinate Mance, knowing full well that even if he succeeded he would never make it out of the camp alive. Mance is stunned that this is what the Night's Watch has come to, and asks if Jon would really kill a man under parley who shared food and drink with him. Given that Jon's own half-brother Robb Stark was murdered in an unthinkable violation of guest right, Mance's accusation stings Jon deeply, and he hesitates for a tense moment. However, before Jon can actually violate guest right, they are interrupted by the surprise arrival of Stannis Baratheon's army.
- Ellaria Sand and the Sand Snakes murder Myrcella Baratheon as revenge for the death of Oberyn Martell, even though Myrcella was an innocent girl who had nothing to do with Oberyn's fate (it was revenge against her mother, Cersei Lannister) and was living in Dorne under the protection of Prince Doran Martell as his ward. All of them are punished for this when they either die in combat or are imprisoned by Cersei.
In the books
In the A Song of Ice and Fire novels, the guest right is an ancient and sacred tradition that goes back thousands of years to the time of the First Men. Bread and salt are the traditional provisions. While all of Westeros holds guest right to be sacred, the Northerners are known for taking it particularly seriously (since being denied food and shelter during the winter usually means death in the North).To violate guest right is to break a sacred covenant that is believed to invoke the wrath of the gods both old and new. Even robber lords and bandits are bound by the ancient laws of hospitality. A bandit may ambush a man, rob him, and even kill him, but even highwaymen would give serious pause before considering inviting a man into their home to eat at their table, then robbing and killing him.
A lord with a bared sword across his knees is making a traditional sign that he is denying guest right. Robb Stark initially denies guest right to Tyrion Lannister, appearing with a bared sword across his knees (in the corresponding Season 1 episode "Cripples, Bastards and Broken Things", a bare sword is across the table he sits at, with his knees underneath) when Tyrion is summoned before him, the traditional gesture of denying guest right, though he subsequently offers hospitality to Tyrion, which the latter then declines.
It is sometimes customary for a host to give "guest gifts" to the departing guests when they leave the host's dwellings; this usually represents the end of the sacred guest right and thus the departing guest is no longer considered under the host's protection, and vice versa. In addition, visiting guests will sometimes offer their host "guest gifts" as gratitude for giving them food and shelter. Technically, right after the "guest gifts" are given, the host may do with the guests as he pleases (and vice-versa) - even kill and bake them into pies.
Highborn hostages, despite being part of a noble's household, sharing their food and drink, and being treated according to their status, are not considered guests, thus they are not subject to the protection of guest right. For example, Theon Greyjoy was technically a ward and prisoner of the Starks at Winterfell, not a guest, thus his seizing of Winterfell and the deaths of the children he passes off as Bran and Rickon, while treason, are not considered a violation of hospitality.
It hasn't been specifically mentioned if guest right is followed by the peoples of Essos, such as the inhabitants of the Free Cities or the Dothraki; however it is generally said that hospitality is one of the basic laws of every civilization in the world.
It should be noted that ever since the Red Wedding, although no other house has committed similar acts of violation, a more lasting stain has been left on the practice of guest right, with safety and security in a strange castle no longer being considered guaranteed.
The Brotherhood Without Banners, which has fallen low since Lady Stoneheart (the reanimated Catelyn Stark) replaced Beric as its leader, also violates the guest right. Except Thoros, none of its members has qualms about that. In the fourth novel, they capture Brienne, Pod and their companion Hyle Hunt, and intend to kill them. Brienne tells one of the attending people, Jeyne Heddle, that they shared food with her sister; Jeyne nonchalantly answers "Guest right don’t mean so much as it used to. Not since m’lady come back from the wedding".
In real life
Guest right, or a variation of it, has been one of the most basic social laws of virtually every civilization since the dawn of recorded history. The most famous version was practiced in ancient Greece, where early epic poets such as Homer and Hesiod relate that violations of the laws of hospitality are considered to be among the gravest of crimes. Zeus himself presided over the laws of hospitality, and in this capacity is referred to variously as Zeus Xenios, Zeus Philoxenon, or Zeus Hospites - xenia being the Greek concept of hospitality.
George R.R. Martin may have drawn inspiration for the story of the Rat Cook from the Greek myth about the curse of the House of Atreus. The two brothers Atreus and Thyestes were feuding over the kingship, and Atreus discovered that Thyestes was having an affair with his own wife Aerope. Atreus exacted revenge by inviting Thyestes to dinner at his home, then secretly killed Thyestes's sons, cooked their meat, and served it to the unknowing Thyestes. After he had finished consuming his own issue, Atreus revealed to Thyestes what he had done and taunted him with the severed heads and hands of his sons. This is the source of modern phrase "Thyestean Feast", one at which human flesh is served. Subsequently, Atreus and his descendants were cursed by the gods and various tragedies befell them across the generations. It was not for cannibalism, however, that the House of Atreus was cursed, but for Atreus's crime of killing his own nephews while they were guests in his home.
It has been argued that in the Book of Genesis, the violation of hospitality is what truly made Sodom and Gomorrah considered to be wicked, resulting in God condemning everyone in the cities to die. In the narrative, God decides to destroy the cities but Abraham implores him to have mercy and spare the cities if even ten righteous people could be found there. God therefore sent two angels disguised as men to Sodom, who were refused hospitality by all until they encounter Abraham's nephew Lot, who had recently moved to Sodom with his family. Lot welcomes the two as guests into his home, and eats with them at his table. A crowd of men from the city later gathers outside of Lot's home and demands that he send the two strangers out of his house, "so that we might know them" (have sex with them). Lot is so horrified at their intentions that he even offers to let the crowd of men voluntarily have sex with his own virgin daughters rather than allow the two men who are his guests to be harmed. The crowd refuses but the angels then reveal their true forms, strike the crowd blind, and warn Lot that he and his family must leave the city at once. Sodom and Gomorrah are destroyed at dawn by God raining down fire and brimstone from the heavens.
Many subsequent generations interpreted the story of Sodom and Gomorrah to be a condemnation of homosexual sex acts (to the point that "sodomy" became a common term for homosexual sex acts), but modern biblical scholars have pointed out that the inhabitants of Sodom are never explicitly condemned for engaging in homosexual sex. Rather, the crowd of men gathered outside Lot's house did not horrify him simply because they wanted to engage in homosexual sex, but because they wanted to rape and harm guests within his own home, whom he had formally extended his protection over as part of guest right. While other books of the bible (i.e. Leviticus) condemn homosexuality, the violation of the laws of hospitality is considered to be an infinitely worse transgression. The Midrash contains numerous commentaries and stories about the villainies of the Sodomites, not particularly focusing on homosexual sex but on their overall cruelty, including accounts of them horribly killing those who showed mercy to the poor.
In modern times, hospitality laws are the only legal remnants of the ancient guest right systems, though within a given culture, many guest right customs might persist. It is akin to the concept of diplomatic immunity, whereby foreign ambassadors are considered inviolate in a host country.
- Guest right on A Wiki of Ice and Fire (MAJOR spoilers from the books)
- Customs on A Wiki of Ice and Fire
- Guest right on Wikipedia
Rebellion · Regicide · Treason · Violation of guest right