Talk:Abduction of Lyanna Stark

Fan theories
I've noticed that the fan theory (the accuracy of which i'm not trying to debate) that Rhaegar may not have kidnapped Lyanna keeps getting added to this page and others related to it. It's getting to the point where it's becoming an edit war, which is why I'm trying to start this discussion, though the main user who is readding this theory is ignoring the discussions I've added to the talk pages of their accounts. This seems inappropriate to me since this is meant to be a wiki, not a fansite that debates theories. Since none of the characters or official series material put the kidnapping into debate (no matter how much we may want to add our own interpretation to certain statements), it seems pretty clear that the theory and other fan bias should not be included. This would of course change once or if the theory proved true. But as it stands now, I see no reason why this theory in particular should be allowed here when any other theory wouldn't be. Arya Baratheon (talk) 19:27, April 13, 2015 (UTC)