User blog comment:Gcheung28/Fan vs. Critic: Game of Thrones - The Laws of Gods and Men/@comment-122.59.245.147-20140518230144

This clearly went to the fan, because Matt said one of the most ridiculous theories I've ever heard, that he thinks Shae was lying and conning Tyrion all along. Perhaps he's basing this off her character in the book, which he shouldn't do because as Greater Good pointed out her character is completely different in the show than it was in the books. They clearly set up in the show that she was actually in love with him, and very jealous, and hurt when he broke up with her. In fact if Matt ends up being right and they do end up revealing Shae was "playing him all along" I'd be outraged, that'd be HORRIBLE writing, and go against everything they established, but I'm confident that D & D are better than that.